Homes for sale in Bay Shore, NY
Bay Shore is a South Shore hamlet in the Town of Islip, right on the Great South Bay. Our office is at 1813 5th Ave.
- Bay Shore LIRR station, on the Montauk Branch.
- Ferries to Fire Island leave from Bay Shore.
- Many Bay Shore addresses are in the Bay Shore school district, but some are in Brentwood. Each listing page shows its district.
Our homes in Bay Shore
Own a home in Bay Shore?
Find out what it is worth from an agent who sells here.
78
homes sold in Bay Shore since 2020
